Osiris wrote:I may be courting controversy here but it seems to me that drugs use is never going to be fully eliminated from sport. From that standpoint why not just level the playing field and make it legal?
For sports like cycling you could have a handicap system in place with those testing positive receiving time penalties perhaps.
I agree with Dugald that its hard to watch sport now, where any seemingly superhuman effort, whether obtained through drug use or not, will always have a question mark over it. Just look at whats been said about Lance Armstrong for instance.
J
I can't agree with you on this Osiris. Your suggestion of course isn't new, I've heard it before. If drugs were acceptable then sports events would simply become a competition among drug companies: best drugs win races, not the best competitors. The drug companies already have their competition on the stock market, let's leave it there. I think Cyclo expresses this idea very well when he says: "
The athlete who responds best to the therapy wins, rather than the best athlete. '
Many aspects of bicyle racing has had handicap systems for years, and I think they served the sport well. Imagine the headaches involved trying to organize a handicap sytem on the basis of testing postive and not testing postive, it would degenerate into the unfair illicit drug use that happens today.
I think Armstrong had his name tarnished long before he ever started racing. One need only go back to the 1980 (?) Los Angeles Olympics when the Yankee cycling team use stored blood to improve their hemoglobin. It wasn't against any rules then, because it wasn't felt that anyone would go to this extent to win, and indeed it wasn't felt that cyclists could have afforded the high financial cost of doing this. Money can afford the drugs and the best means of avoiding detection, so Armstrong, not lacking backers or money, was under a cloud of suspicion even although he may have been absolutely innocent of taking drugs.
An added reason for outlawing the use of drugs is the absence of sound knowledge as to what the long-term effect of these 'modern' drugs might be. Look what happened to our Tommy Simpson, and that wasn't the long-term effect. Oh, then there's Pantani, and he's dead!
No Osiris, I don't think drugs would ever give any sport a level playing field. Let's leave drugs to the druggies!