Re: Carbuncle Awards 2008
Posted: Tue Nov 27, 2007 10:09 am
Im sure they had a hard decision for worst planning decision - It would take me a good while to go through the dross thats being agreed!
To post in the forums you will need to first register. All new members are welcomed, with one caveat: You must behave and be nice AND SEARCH BEFORE POSTING!
http://www.hiddenglasgow.com/forums/
http://www.hiddenglasgow.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=25&t=6761
Dexter St. Clair wrote:I nominate the St Mungo Museum of Religious Life and Art.
an eighties carbuncle.
Dexter St. Clair wrote:I nominate the St Mungo Museum of Religious Life and Art.
an eighties carbuncle.
This is an academy, the pride of Britain's schools system. The academy programme has created a generation of buildings that by and large are made of render, in white and coloured panels, designed by terrible architects like Ryder who treat them like just another developer piece of shit.
ARCHIAL, I AM TRYING REALLY HARD NOT TO PUBLISH SO MUCH OF YOUR SHIT. I HAVE NO PARTICULAR AGENDA, I DON'T WANT TO HATE YOU ANY MORE THAN ANY OF THE OTHER SHIT ARCHITECTS IN THIS COUNTRY. BUT IT IS IMPOSSIBLE WHEN YOU KEEP SENDING OUT IMAGES LIKE THIS.
THIS IS A HOUSING DEVELOPMENT (DESPITE LOOKING MUCH LIKE A 1980S BUSINESS PARK). IT'S IN A CONSERVATION AREA IN EDINBURGH AND HAS PLANNING PERMISSION.
ARCHIAL'S IDEAS ARE SO PISS WEAK THAT THE DRAWING KIND OF FADES INTO TRANSLUCENCY. THE CAD/SKETCHUP MONKEY WAS PRESUMABLY SIMULATING THE LIMP-WRISTED INABILITY OF ARCHIAL'S DRAFSTMEN TO PUSH DOWN HARD ENOUGH ON THE FUCKING FELT TIP.
gap74 wrote:I'm also rapidly coming to the conclusion that very little that has been built in the last twenty years is of much merit - there's an Emperor's New Clothes aspect to it, where architects cry us all as ignorant if we criticise modern stuff, but there's no denying that a huge majority of it is just shit, both in terms of design and materials. I know we live in an age of value engineering, but have these people no desire to create something which is, you know, aesthetic for aesthetic's sake?
And I agree, hazy - I mourn the loss of a vernacular architecture.